
By Michelle F.
Covered in a sporadically placed assortment of stickers, the windows of the Princeton Record Exchange sit patiently, waiting to see the reflection of its regular customers, sometimes up to twice a day. Situated in a quiet corner of downtown Princeton, the magnetic pull of the store can be undeniably felt from blocks down Nassau street. For regulars, these welcoming walls contain a sanctuary for first dates, marriage proposals, and even wedding ceremonies. Since 1980, the store’s 3,800 square feet of over 100,000 vinyl records and CDs have been home to the widest imaginable variety of customers, stretching from locals to tourists. “People enjoy being there as an event. It’s like going bowling or getting a drink, it’s going to the record store. You put your dirty clothes on, you say hello to your favorite people. It’s real,” explains owner Jon Lambert.
Following the 2020 COVID pandemic, businesses all over the world took a hard hit, with over 700,000 establishments shutting down in the second quarter, according to the Federal Reserve. After re-opening for the first time since the pandemic, Lambert was greeted by a line of 40 masked, socially-distanced people that stretched “almost all the way down” the street,” he said.
“Thank you so much for being here. Thank god you made it” were the first words Lambert heard after swinging ajar his stickered doors. When asked how he felt about the sight, Lambert explained he felt “relief, and happiness that maybe we could make it.” Lambert expressed that though he was still struggling financially after the closure, he held onto hope of the business recovering. But overcoming these strenuous obstacles only grew stronger connections between the customers and their safehouse. “It was nightmarish, but to watch the transition, and feel an increase in loyalty and an increase in appreciation for what we can offer to people, that’s really important. It’s really important to people, and I love that. It’s great to be able to [provide that].”
The town of Princeton is home to around 30,000 residents, with the entire population admittedly not being record collectors. Lambert explains that the exchange relies on the bigger community to keep business booming. “People that come to our place, everywhere they go, they talk about this wonderful store. One of my customers said he wouldn’t move. He needs that [record] fix. There’s people who regularly come from New York, Washington, Boston, and of course the tourists when they come to town.” On Nassau Street, the record store acts as an anchor. A place that people can trust and rely on. “It’s fun to be a part of the community. At this point, we have three generations of people shopping at [the Princeton] organizations.” elaborates Lambert.
The loyalty that customers have for Princeton Record Exchange is not one-sided. Lambert asserts he has a strong passion for customer service, reciprocating the same level of commitment by deliberately listening and responding to customer needs, a characteristic unique to the freedom that comes with owning an independent business. “I totally remodeled the store to make it more comfortable,” Lambert said. He emphasized that spending $30,000 to replace the air conditioning unit in the store wasn’t an easy decision, but it was worth it for the sake of his customers’ comfort. “When you’re independent, you can try things. You’re like, hey, let’s rearrange this section, let’s try incorporating soul and thumb. You can try things and see if they work or not, and then you can pivot. It’s fun not to be constrained.” As for the tight knit team, Lambert follows a thorough interview process, handpicking 17 employees, ensuring that the intentions of the people working for the store align with the passionate motives of Princeton Record Exchange. “You know what I care about? I care about people who can be warm and welcoming, who can look people in the eye, who want to make it an enjoyable experience for people in the store.”
The undeniable charm of Princeton Record Exchange fosters a sturdy sense of loyalty and commitment from both customers and merchants. On the quiet corner of Nassau, its stickered doors are always open. However, when visiting the establishment, it is important to follow Lambert’s strictly enforced policy. “In the store, no [playing] death metal,” he said. “We’re not here to piss people off.”

